Consumer participation and satisfaction with digital green inclusive financial products

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-1524.2021.08.21

Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis ›› 2021, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (8): 1542-1551.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1004-1524.2021.08.21

• Agricultural Economy and Development • Previous Articles Next Articles

Consumer participation and satisfaction with digital green inclusive financial products

YAO Xingyuan(), WANG Weifang

Zhejiang Financial College, Hangzhou 310018, China

Received:2021-04-15 Online:2021-08-25 Published:2021-08-27

Abstract

Abstract:

Consumer participation showed an impact on the satisfaction of digital green inclusion financial products, thus contributing to the promotion of rural revitalization, the achievement of the dual carbon goals, and the promotion of high-quality development. Based on the micro questionnaire survey data, empirical research found that the improvement of participation identification and the increase of participation behavior had a positive impact on the satisfaction of digital green inclusive financial products. Relatively, participation identification and social engagement had a greater positive impact on overall satisfaction;the influence of participation depth was greater than that of participation density. The influence of specific participation on satisfaction of different dimensions was heterogeneous. Therefore, in the design of financial products and services, attention should be paid to the positive impact of participation on satisfaction and its heterogeneity. In particular, attention should be paid to the positive role of online social participation as well as enriching various forms of participation.

Key words: participation behavior, low carbon consumption, inclusive finance, green finance, digital finance, satisfaction

CLC Number:

S-9
F831.2

YAO Xingyuan, WANG Weifang. Consumer participation and satisfaction with digital green inclusive financial products[J]. Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis, 2021, 33(8): 1542-1551.

Figures/Tables 5

References 28

[1]	KASMAN A, DUMAN Y S. CO₂ emissions, economic growth, energy consumption, trade and urbanization in new EU member and candidate countries: a panel data analysis[J]. Economic Modelling, 2015, 44:97-103. DOI URL
[2]	陈欣, 刘明. 金融发展对二氧化碳排放影响的经验研究[J]. 财经问题研究, 2015(4):40-46.
	CHEN X, LIU M. Empirical study on the impact of financial development on carbon dioxide emissions[J]. Research on Financial and Economic Issues, 2015(4):40-46.(in Chinese)
[3]	MAJI K J, DIKSHIT A K, DESHPANDE A. Disability-adjusted life years and economic cost assessment of the health effects related to PM_2.5 and PM₁₀ pollution in Mumbai and Delhi, in India from 1991 to 2015[J]. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2017, 24(5):4709-4730. DOI URL
[4]	PARK Y, MENG F C, BALOCH M A. The effect of ICT, financial development, growth, and trade openness on CO₂ emissions: an empirical analysis[J]. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2018, 25(30):30708-30719. DOI URL
[5]	SADORSKY P. Financial development and energy consumption in Central and Eastern European frontier economies[J]. Energy Policy, 2011, 39(2):999-1006. DOI URL
[6]	TAMAZIAN A, CHOUSA J P, VADLAMANNATI K C. Does higher economic and financial development lead to environmental degradation: evidence from BRIC countries[J]. Energy Policy, 2009, 37(1):246-253. DOI URL
[7]	MAHALIK M K, MALLICK H. Energy consumption, economic growth and financial development: exploring the empirical linkages for India[J]. The Journal of Developing Areas, 2014, 48(4):139-159. DOI URL
[8]	姚星垣. 金融发展、全要素生产率与碳排放: 来自G20的证据[J]. 环境经济研究, 2019, 4(1):22-38.
	YAO X Y. Financial development, total factor productivity and carbon emissions: evidence from G20[J]. Journal of Environmental Economics, 2019, 4(1):22-38.(in Chinese with English abstract)
[9]	YAO X Y, TANG X B. Does financial structure affect CO₂ emissions? Evidence from G20 countries[J]. Finance Research Letters, 2021, 41:101791. DOI URL
[10]	姜再勇. 绿色普惠金融探析[J]. 中国金融, 2018,(18):52-54.
	JIANG Z Y. The exploration and analysis of green inclusive finance[J]. China Finance, 2018,(18):52-54.(in Chinese)
[11]	张明哲. 供给侧改革助推绿色普惠金融发展[J]. 清华金融评论, 2020(2):72-74.
	ZHANG M Z. Supply-side reform boosting the development of green inclusive finance[J]. Tsinghua Financial Review, 2020(2):72-74.(in Chinese)
[12]	马莲贵. 以绿色普惠金融推动乡村振兴步坦途[J]. 中国农村金融, 2019(2):70-71.
	MA L G. Promoting the smooth path of rural revitalization through green inclusive finance[J]. China Rural Finance, 2019(2):70-71.(in Chinese)
[13]	金辉. 走可持续的绿色普惠金融发展之路[J]. 中国农村金融, 2019(24):60-62.
	JIN H. Taking the sustainable road of green inclusive finance development[J]. China Rural Finance, 2019(24):60-62.(in Chinese)
[14]	蒋庆正, 李红, 刘香甜. 农村数字普惠金融发展水平测度及影响因素研究[J]. 金融经济学研究, 2019, 34(4):123-133.
	JIANG Q Z, LI H, LIU X T. The measurement of the development level of digital inclusive finance in rural areas and its influencing factors[J]. Financial Economics Research, 2019, 34(4):123-133.(in Chinese with English abstract)
[15]	刘丹, 方锐, 汤颖梅. 数字普惠金融发展对农民非农收入的空间溢出效应[J]. 金融经济学研究, 2019, 34(3):57-66.
	LIU D, FANG R, TANG Y M. The spatial spillover effect of the development of digital inclusive finance on farmers’ non-agricultural income[J]. Financial Economics Research, 2019, 34(3):57-66.(in Chinese with English abstract)
[16]	傅秋子, 黄益平. 数字金融对农村金融需求的异质性影响: 来自中国家庭金融调查与北京大学数字普惠金融指数的证据[J]. 金融研究, 2018,(11):68-84.
	FU Q Z, HUANG Y P. Digital finance’s heterogeneous effects on rural financial demand: evidence from China household finance survey and inclusive digital finance index[J]. Journal of Financial Research, 2018,(11):68-84.(in Chinese with English abstract)
[17]	易行健, 周利. 数字普惠金融发展是否显著影响了居民消费: 来自中国家庭的微观证据[J]. 金融研究, 2018(11):47-67.
	YI X J, ZHOU L. Does digital financial inclusion significantly influence household consumption? evidence from household survey data in China[J]. Journal of Financial Research, 2018(11):47-67.(in Chinese with English abstract)
[18]	LUNT P K, LIVINGSTONE S. Mass consumption and personal identity: everyday economic experience[M]. Buckingham: Open University Press, 1992.
[19]	王宁. 消费与认同: 对消费社会学的一个分析框架的探索[J]. 社会学研究, 2001, 16(1):4-14.
	WANG N. Consumption and identify[J]. Sociological Research, 2001, 16(1):4-14.(in Chinese with English abstract)
[20]	郑秋莹, 姚唐, 曹花蕊, 等. 是单纯享乐还是自我实现?顾客参与生产性消费的体验价值[J]. 心理科学进展, 2017, 25(2):191-200.
	ZHENG Q Y, YAO T, CAO H R, et al. Hedonic enjoyment or eudaimonia?The experiential value of productive consumption[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2017, 25(2):191-200.(in Chinese with English abstract)
[21]	岳秋荧. 顾客参与、服务质量感知与持续消费: 以线上零售为切入点[J]. 商业经济研究, 2019(22):83-86.
	YUE Q Y. Customer participation, perception of service quality and continuous consumption: taking online retail as the entry point[J]. Journal of Commercial Economics, 2019(22):83-86.(in Chinese)
[22]	邱晔, 刘保中, 黄群慧. 功能、感官、情感: 不同产品体验对顾客满意度和忠诚度的影响[J]. 消费经济, 2017, 33(4):59-67.
	QIU Y, LIU B Z, HUANG Q H. Functional, sensory, affective: effect of different product experience on customer satisfaction and loyalty[J]. Consumer Economics, 2017, 33(4):59-67.(in Chinese with English abstract)
[23]	唐晓莉, 宋之杰. 共享经济参与主体协同消费行为的演化博弈分析[J]. 企业经济, 2019, 38(1):66-72.
	TANG X L, SONG Z J. An evolutionary game analysis of collaborative consumption behavior of participants in sharing economy[J]. Enterprise Economy, 2019, 38(1):66-72.(in Chinese)
[24]	杜淑琳. 共享经济背景下消费者参与协同消费的影响要素探究[J]. 商业经济研究, 2018(13):48-50.
	DU S L. Research on influencing factors of consumer participation in collaborative consumption in the context of sharing economy[J]. Journal of Commercial Economics, 2018(13):48-50.(in Chinese)
[25]	周衍鲁, 周挺辉. 消费金融发展现状及未来趋势: 关于市场参与主体运营模式差异化研究[J]. 商业经济研究, 2018(20):152-154.
	ZHOU Y L, ZHOU T H. Development status and future trend of consumer finance: a study on differentiation of operation mode of market participants[J]. Journal of Commercial Economics, 2018(20):152-154.(in Chinese)
[26]	张霞. 浙江省家庭农场金融支持的现状、问题及对策研究[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2015, 27(6):1096-1101.
	ZHANG X. Financial support in development of family farms in Zhejiang Province: present situation, problems and countermeasures[J]. Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis, 2015, 27(6):1096-1101.(in Chinese with English abstract)
[27]	文长存, 孙玉竹. 农户对区域指数类农业附加险购买意愿的实证研究: 以河北棉花种植户为例[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2021, 33(2):346-354.
	WEN C C, SUN Y Z. Analysis on farmers' willingness to buy agricultural accessory risk based on regional index in China: a case study on cotton growers in Hebei Province[J]. Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis, 2021, 33(2):346-354.(in Chinese with English abstract)
[28]	李伟. 做好数据治理推动数字化转型[J]. 中国金融, 2020(1):43-45.
	LI W. Special topic: advancing the digitalization transformation of financial industry[J]. China Finance, 2020(1):43-45.(in Chinese)

变量 Variable	变量说明 Variable description	变量取值 Value of a variable
满意度 Satisfaction	总体满意度 Overall satisfaction	非常满意=5,满意=4,一般=3,不满意=2,非常不满意=1 Very satisfied=5, satisfied=4, average=3, dissatisfied=2, very dissatisfied=1
丰富性满意度 SatisKind	绿色能量种类满意度 Satisfaction with the type of green energy
便捷性满意度 SatisTime	收集绿色能量时长满意度 Satisfaction with how long it takes to collect green energy
激励性满意度 SatisAmount	收集绿色能量数量满意度 Satisfaction with the amount of green energy collected
种树数量 TreeNumber	目前拥有树的数量 The number of trees you have so far	没有=0,1棵=1,2棵=2,3棵=3,4棵及以上=4 No tree=0,1 tree=1,2 trees=2,3 trees=3,4 trees and above=4
种树时间 TreeTime	平均种植一棵新树所需时间 The average time it takes to plant a new tree	1月以内=5,1~3月=4,3~6月=3,6~9月=2,9月以上=1 Less than 1 month=5, 1-3 months=4, 3-6 months=3, 6-9 months=2, more than 9 months=1
参与认同 Participate	认同数字绿色普惠金融产品的参与功能 Agreed with the participation function of DGIF	非常同意=5,同意=4,一般=3,不同意=2,非常不同意=1 Strongly agree=5, agree=4, generally=3, disagree=2, stronglydisagree=1
社交参与 Communication	认同绿色低碳消费者之间的彼此互动 Agreed with interaction between consumers of DGIF
绿色出行 Travel	采用步行、公交、地铁等绿色出行方式 Adopt walking, bus, subway and other green travel modes	采取这种方式收集绿色能量=1,不采取这种方式收集能量=0 Take this way to collect green energy=1, otherwise=0
线上购票 Tickets	通过线上方式进行购票 Purchase tickets online
线上支付 EPayment	采用线上支付方式消费 Use online payment for consumption
生活缴费 Utilities	线上交纳水电气等费用 Pay utilities online
电子发票 EInvoice	开具或接受电子发票 Issue or accept electronic invoices
线上挂号 EAppoiment	网上预约挂号就诊 Online appointment for medical treatment
其他方式 Other	采取其他参与方式 Take other forms of participation
性别 Sex	性别 Gender	男性=1,女性=2 Male=1, female=2
年龄 Age	年龄 Age	14岁及以下=1,15-19岁=2,20-29岁=3,30-39岁=4,40岁及以上=5 14 and below=1,15 to 19=2,20 to 29=3,30 to 39=4,40 and above=5
教育水平 Education	您的最高学历水平 Highest educational level	初中及以下=1,高中、中职=2,大专、高职=3,大学本科=4,硕士研究生及以上=5 Middle school and below=1, high school=2,junior college=3, undergraduate=4, graduate and above=5

变量 Variable	变量说明 Variable description	变量取值 Value of a variable
满意度 Satisfaction	总体满意度 Overall satisfaction	非常满意=5,满意=4,一般=3,不满意=2,非常不满意=1 Very satisfied=5, satisfied=4, average=3, dissatisfied=2, very dissatisfied=1
丰富性满意度 SatisKind	绿色能量种类满意度 Satisfaction with the type of green energy
便捷性满意度 SatisTime	收集绿色能量时长满意度 Satisfaction with how long it takes to collect green energy
激励性满意度 SatisAmount	收集绿色能量数量满意度 Satisfaction with the amount of green energy collected
种树数量 TreeNumber	目前拥有树的数量 The number of trees you have so far	没有=0,1棵=1,2棵=2,3棵=3,4棵及以上=4 No tree=0,1 tree=1,2 trees=2,3 trees=3,4 trees and above=4
种树时间 TreeTime	平均种植一棵新树所需时间 The average time it takes to plant a new tree	1月以内=5,1~3月=4,3~6月=3,6~9月=2,9月以上=1 Less than 1 month=5, 1-3 months=4, 3-6 months=3, 6-9 months=2, more than 9 months=1
参与认同 Participate	认同数字绿色普惠金融产品的参与功能 Agreed with the participation function of DGIF	非常同意=5,同意=4,一般=3,不同意=2,非常不同意=1 Strongly agree=5, agree=4, generally=3, disagree=2, stronglydisagree=1
社交参与 Communication	认同绿色低碳消费者之间的彼此互动 Agreed with interaction between consumers of DGIF
绿色出行 Travel	采用步行、公交、地铁等绿色出行方式 Adopt walking, bus, subway and other green travel modes	采取这种方式收集绿色能量=1,不采取这种方式收集能量=0 Take this way to collect green energy=1, otherwise=0
线上购票 Tickets	通过线上方式进行购票 Purchase tickets online
线上支付 EPayment	采用线上支付方式消费 Use online payment for consumption
生活缴费 Utilities	线上交纳水电气等费用 Pay utilities online
电子发票 EInvoice	开具或接受电子发票 Issue or accept electronic invoices
线上挂号 EAppoiment	网上预约挂号就诊 Online appointment for medical treatment
其他方式 Other	采取其他参与方式 Take other forms of participation
性别 Sex	性别 Gender	男性=1,女性=2 Male=1, female=2
年龄 Age	年龄 Age	14岁及以下=1,15-19岁=2,20-29岁=3,30-39岁=4,40岁及以上=5 14 and below=1,15 to 19=2,20 to 29=3,30 to 39=4,40 and above=5
教育水平 Education	您的最高学历水平 Highest educational level	初中及以下=1,高中、中职=2,大专、高职=3,大学本科=4,硕士研究生及以上=5 Middle school and below=1, high school=2,junior college=3, undergraduate=4, graduate and above=5

变量Variable	均值Mean	标准差SD	最小值Min	中位数Median	最大值Max
满意度Satisfaction	3.908	0.695	1	4	5
丰富性满意度SatisKind	3.763	0.752	1	4	5
便捷性满意度SatisTime	3.501	0.874	1	3	5
激励性满意度SatisAmount	3.593	0.798	1	4	5
参与认同Participate	3.903	0.816	1	4	5
社交参与Communication	3.633	0.895	1	4	5
种树数量TreeNumber	2.534	1.139	1	2	5
种树时间TreeTime	3.588	1.327	1	4	5
绿色出行Travel	0.887	0.317	0	1	1
线上购票Tickets	0.693	0.462	0	1	1
线上支付EPayment	0.887	0.317	0	1	1
生活缴费Utilities	0.388	0.488	0	0	1
电子发票EInvoice	0.151	0.358	0	0	1
线上挂号EAppoiment	0.105	0.307	0	0	1
其他方式Other	0.340	0.474	0	0	1
性别Sex	1.706	0.456	1	2	2
年龄Age	3.806	0.593	1	4	7
教育水平Education	3.367	0.641	1	3	6

变量Variable	均值Mean	标准差SD	最小值Min	中位数Median	最大值Max
满意度Satisfaction	3.908	0.695	1	4	5
丰富性满意度SatisKind	3.763	0.752	1	4	5
便捷性满意度SatisTime	3.501	0.874	1	3	5
激励性满意度SatisAmount	3.593	0.798	1	4	5
参与认同Participate	3.903	0.816	1	4	5
社交参与Communication	3.633	0.895	1	4	5
种树数量TreeNumber	2.534	1.139	1	2	5
种树时间TreeTime	3.588	1.327	1	4	5
绿色出行Travel	0.887	0.317	0	1	1
线上购票Tickets	0.693	0.462	0	1	1
线上支付EPayment	0.887	0.317	0	1	1
生活缴费Utilities	0.388	0.488	0	0	1
电子发票EInvoice	0.151	0.358	0	0	1
线上挂号EAppoiment	0.105	0.307	0	0	1
其他方式Other	0.340	0.474	0	0	1
性别Sex	1.706	0.456	1	2	2
年龄Age	3.806	0.593	1	4	7
教育水平Education	3.367	0.641	1	3	6

变量Variable	(1)	(2)	(3)	(4)	(5)
参与认同Participate	0.276^***				0.214^***
	(7.13)				(5.39)
种树数量TreeNumber		0.084^***			0.050^**
		(3.85)			(2.19)
种树时间TreeTime			0.041^**		0.027
			(2.28)		(1.47)
社交参与Communication				0.195^***	0.141^***
				(6.02)	(4.36)
性别Sex	0.001	-0.023	-0.004	-0.009	-0.014
	(0.01)	(-0.44)	(-0.07)	(-0.19)	(-0.29)
年龄Age	-0.016	-0.042	-0.024	-0.004	-0.018
	(-0.44)	(-1.11)	(-0.62)	(-0.11)	(-0.51)
教育水平Education	0.005	0.004	-0.002	-0.009	0.003
	(0.14)	(0.09)	(-0.04)	(-0.24)	(0.09)
常数项Constant	0.764^***	1.006^***	0.893^***	0.793^***	0.736^***
	(2.71)	(3.44)	(3.03)	(2.77)	(2.66)
观察值 Observations	468	468	468	468	468
R²	0.533	0.498	0.487	0.519	0.563
AdjR²	0.524	0.488	0.477	0.510	0.551

Consumer participation and satisfaction with digital green inclusive financial products

RichHTML

PDF (PC)

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 5

References 28

Related Articles 3

Recommended Articles

Metrics

Comments

变量Variable	(1)	(2)	(3)
被解释变量Explained variable	丰富性满意度SatisKind	便捷性满意度SatisTime	激励性满意度SatisAmount
参与认同Participate	0.153^***	0.102^*	0.067
	(2.89)	(1.69)	(1.16)
社交参与Communication	0.265^***	0.330^***	0.242^***
	(5.99)	(6.55)	(5.05)
绿色出行Travel	-0.028	-0.009	-0.084
	(-0.28)	(-0.07)	(-0.77)
线上购票Tickets	-0.048	0.079	0.011
	(-0.65)	(0.92)	(0.14)
线上支付EPayment	0.196^*	-0.089	-0.013
	(1.66)	(-0.66)	(-0.10)
生活缴费Utilities	-0.016	0.003	-0.017
	(-0.23)	(0.03)	(-0.22)
电子发票EInvoice	-0.090	-0.186	-0.129
	(-0.79)	(-1.43)	(-1.05)
线上挂号EAppoiment	0.158	0.440^***	0.301^**
	(1.22)	(2.98)	(2.15)
其他方式Other	0.078	0.058	0.163^**
	(1.19)	(0.77)	(2.29)
性别Sex	-0.022	-0.127^*	-0.027
	(-0.34)	(-1.68)	(-0.38)
年龄Age	0.089^*	0.082	0.031
	(1.84)	(1.48)	(0.59)
教育水平Education	-0.046	-0.166^***	-0.165^***
	(-0.95)	(-2.98)	(-3.13)
常数项Constant	0.821^**	1.350^***	1.446^***
	(2.18)	(3.14)	(3.54)
观察值 Observations	468	468	468
R²	0.377	0.361	0.342
AdjR²	0.35	0.34	0.32

变量Variable	(1)	(2)	(3)	(4)	(5)
参与认同Participate	1.289^***				1.013^***
	(6.63)				(5.09)
种树数量TreeNumber		0.359^***			0.210^*
		(3.54)			(1.78)
种树时间TreeTime			0.192^**		0.161^*
			(2.40)		(1.71)
社交参与Communication				0.948^***	0.739^***
				(5.99)	(4.54)
性别Sex	0.010	-0.074	0.022	-0.023	-0.088
	(0.04)	(-0.31)	(0.10)	(-0.10)	(-0.36)
年龄Age	-0.062	-0.200	-0.126	-0.008	-0.048
	(-0.34)	(-1.13)	(-0.72)	(-0.04)	(-0.25)
教育水平Education	0.061	0.021	0.009	-0.021	0.040
	(0.34)	(0.12)	(0.05)	(-0.12)	(0.21)
第1截位Cut1	6.248^***	4.540^***	5.038^***	5.663^***	6.762^***
	(3.51)	(2.70)	(2.98)	(3.25)	(3.67)
第2截位Cut2	7.864^***	6.014^***	6.499^***	7.235^***	8.415^***
	(5.08)	(4.17)	(4.48)	(4.80)	(5.23)
第3截位Cut3	13.308^***	11.246^***	11.712^***	12.768^***	14.079^***
	(8.53)	(7.84)	(8.10)	(8.45)	(8.62)
第4截位Cut4	17.677^***	15.346^***	15.753^***	16.973^***	18.643^***
	(10.51)	(9.99)	(10.18)	(10.49)	(10.59)
观察值 Observations	468	468	468	468	468

[1]	JIN Liwen, LIU Zengjin, LIU Aijun. Participation behavior of pork seller in traceability system: empirical analysis of 636 sellers in Beijing, Shanghai and Jinan, China [J]. Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis, 2021, 33(3): 541-552.
[2]	KE Fuyan, XU Zhiyuan, ZHAN Jinrong. Influencing factors of consumer satisfaction evaluation on quality and safety of agricultural products: an illustration from Zhejiang Province [J]. Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis, 2020, 32(12): 2271-2281.
[3]	SU Fei;PANG Ling\\|feng*;MA Li\\|sha. The impact of livelihood capital on the life satisfaction of urban migrant workers in Hangzhou [J]. , 2014, 26(1): 0-246.