滩涂贝类及其养殖环境中16种农药残留的同步检测与膳食暴露风险评估

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-1524.20250371

浙江农业学报 ›› 2026, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (4): 769-780.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1004-1524.20250371

滩涂贝类及其养殖环境中16种农药残留的同步检测与膳食暴露风险评估

朱洁¹^,²^,³^,⁴(), 徐汇镔¹^,²^,³^,⁴, 项林敏⁵, 胡园¹^,²^,³^,⁴, 陆荣茂¹^,²^,³^,⁴, 蔡景波¹^,²^,³^,⁴^,^*()

¹ 浙江省海洋水产养殖研究所, 浙江温州 325000
² 全省近岸生物种质资源保护与利用重点实验室, 浙江温州 325000
³ 浙江-泰国海洋技术联合实验室, 浙江温州 325000
⁴ 温州市海洋生物遗传育种重点实验室, 浙江温州 325000
⁵ 温州市质量技术检测科学研究院, 浙江温州 325013

收稿日期:2025-05-12 出版日期:2026-04-25 发布日期:2026-05-08
作者简介:*蔡景波,E-mail: jingbocai@163.com
朱洁,从事水产品质量安全研究工作。E-mail:441871423@qq.com
通讯作者: 蔡景波
基金资助:
浙江省基础公益研究计划省自然科学基金项目(LTGC23B050007);浙江省“三农九方”科技协作计划(2025SNJF095);温州市科技特派员项目(X2023091);2024年温州市基础性科研项目(N20240015)

Simultaneous detection and dietary exposure risk assessment of 16 pesticides in mudflat shellfish and mariculture environment

ZHU Jie¹^,²^,³^,⁴(), XU Huibin¹^,²^,³^,⁴, XIANG Linmin⁵, HU Yuan¹^,²^,³^,⁴, LU Rongmao¹^,²^,³^,⁴, CAI Jingbo¹^,²^,³^,⁴^,^*()

¹ Zhejiang Mariculture Research Institute, Wenzhou 325000, Zhejiang, China
² Zhejiang Key Laboratory of Coastal Biological Germplasm Resources Conservation and Utilization, Wenzhou 325000, Zhejiang, China
³ Sino-Thai Joint Laboratory of Marine Science and Technology, Wenzhou 325000, Zhejiang, China
⁴ Wenzhou Key Laboratory of Marine Biological Genetics and Breeding, Wenzhou 325000, Zhejiang, China
⁵ Wenzhou Quality and Technology Testing Research Institute, Wenzhou 325013, Zhejiang, China

Received:2025-05-12 Published:2026-04-25 Online:2026-05-08
Contact: CAI Jingbo

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

为掌握浙江滩涂养殖质量安全状况,建立了一套分散固相萃取结合超高效液相色谱质谱联用法同步测定有机磷类、拟除虫菊酯类和大环内酯类共16种农药残留的检测方法,该法同时适用于水产品及其养殖环境。样品采用2%乙酸酸化乙腈溶液提取,提取液、QuEChERS萃取盐包、QuEChERS净化管净化后上机分析。应用该法筛查了2024—2025年浙南典型养殖区滩涂贝类及其养殖环境中16种农药的残留水平,并对其中检出的农药进行膳食暴露风险评估。结果表明:建立的检测方法对16种农药在1~50 ng·mL^-1范围内线性关系良好,决定系数(R²)均大于0.995;在4个添加水平(4、10、20、50 μg·kg^-1)下的回收率为65.21%~120.00%,相对标准偏差为0.24%~11.17%。建立的检测方法对三唑磷的定量限在生物体中为0.1 μg·kg^-1,在沉积物和水样中分别为0.5 μg·kg^-1和0.5 μg·L^-1;对其他15种目标物的定量限在生物体中为0.2~4.0 μg·kg^-1,在沉积物和水样中分别为0.8~10.0 μg·kg^-1和0.8~10.0 μg·L^-1。用建立的方法从检测的贝类样品中检出三唑磷、甲氰菊酯2种农药残留,从沉积物中检出三唑磷残留,但未从水样中检出农药残留。检出的两种农药的慢性膳食风险为0.007%~0.578%,急性膳食风险为0.845%~51.798%,均低于100%,风险处于可接受范围。

关键词: 滩涂贝类, 农药残留, 养殖环境, 监测, 膳食暴露, 风险评估

Abstract:

To clarify the quality and safety status of coastal mudflat mariculture in Zhejiang Province of China, a sensitive analytical method was established for the simultaneous determination of 16 pesticide residues (including organophosphorus, pyrethroid, and macrolide pesticides) in aquatic products and their mariculture environment using dispersive solid-phase extraction coupled with ultra-high performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. Samples were extracted with 2% acetic acid in acetonitrile, and the extracts were purified using QuEChERS extraction salt packets and QuEChERS cleanup tubes prior to instrumental analysis. This method was applied to determine the residual levels of the 16 target pesticides in mudflat shellfish and their mariculture environment from typical mariculture areas in southern Zhejiang during 2024-2025, and a dietary exposure risk assessment was conducted for the detected pesticides. It was shown that the established method exhibited good linearity for all 16 pesticides in the concentration range of 1-50 ng·mL^-1, with coefficients of determination (R²) all exceeding 0.995. The recoveries at four spiked levels (4, 10, 20, and 50 μg·kg^-1) ranged from 65.21% to 120.00%, with relative standard deviations (RSDs) of 0.24%-11.17%. The limit of quantification (LOQ) of triazophos was 0.1 μg·kg^-1 in biological samples, 0.5 μg·kg^-1 in sediment samples, and 0.5 μg·L^-1 in water samples; for the other 15 target pesticides, the LOQs were 0.2-4.0 μg·kg^-1 in biological samples, 0.8-10.0 μg·kg^-1 in sediment samples, and 0.8-10.0 μg·L^-1 in water samples. By using the established method, triazophos and fenpropathrin residues were detected in shellfish samples, and triazophos residue was detected in sediment samples, while no pesticide residues were found in water samples. The chronic dietary risk of the two detected pesticides ranged from 0.007% to 0.578%, and the acute dietary risk ranged from 0.845% to 51.798%, all below 100%, indicating that the dietary exposure risks were within an acceptable range.

Key words: mudflat shellfish, pesticide residues, mariculture environment, monitor, dietary exposure, risk assessment

中图分类号:

S931.3

朱洁, 徐汇镔, 项林敏, 胡园, 陆荣茂, 蔡景波. 滩涂贝类及其养殖环境中16种农药残留的同步检测与膳食暴露风险评估[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2026, 38(4): 769-780.

ZHU Jie, XU Huibin, XIANG Linmin, HU Yuan, LU Rongmao, CAI Jingbo. Simultaneous detection and dietary exposure risk assessment of 16 pesticides in mudflat shellfish and mariculture environment[J]. Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis, 2026, 38(4): 769-780.

图/表 10

参考文献 35

[1]	尤仲杰, 徐善良, 谢起浪. 浙江沿岸的贝类资源及其增养殖[J]. 东海海洋, 2000, 18(1): 50-56.
	YOU Z J, XU S L, XIE Q L. Shellfish resources and its cultivation and proliferation along Zhejiang coast[J]. Donghai Marine Science, 2000, 18(1): 50-56.
[2]	林志华, 尤仲杰. 浙江滩涂贝类养殖高产技术模式[J]. 海洋科学, 2005, 29(8): 95-99.
	LIN Z H, YOU Z J. Intensive mudflat bivalves culture in Zhejiang[J]. Marine Sciences, 2005, 29(8): 95-99.
[3]	林志华, 何琳, 董迎辉. 浙江滩涂贝类种业科技创新发展及展望[J]. 水产学报, 2023, 47(1): 109-124.
	LIN Z H, HE L, DONG Y H. Development and prospect for scientific and technological innovation of mudflat mollusk breeding industry in Zhejiang[J]. Journal of Fisheries of China, 2023, 47(1): 109-124.
[4]	田耿智, 白新明, 刘晓庆, 等. 农药残留风险评估在蔬菜水果和食用菌监测中的应用研究[J]. 核农学报, 2022, 36(2): 402-413.
	TIAN G Z, BAI X M, LIU X Q, et al. Study on the application of a risk assessment method of pesticide residues in vegetables and fruits and edible fungus monitoring[J]. Journal of Nuclear Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 36(2): 402-413.
[5]	薛超波, 刘慧慧, 王国良, 等. 海洋滩涂沉积物环境中三唑磷残留的GC/MS检测[J]. 中国卫生检验杂志, 2006, 16(5): 522-523.
	XUE C B, LIU H H, WANG G L, et al. Determination of triazophos residues in marine shoal mud by GC/MS[J]. Chinese Journal of Health Laboratory Technology, 2006, 16(5): 522-523.
[6]	李永玉, 洪华生, 王新红, 等. 厦门海域有机磷农药污染现状与来源分析[J]. 环境科学学报, 2005, 25(8): 1071-1077.
	LI Y Y, HONG H S, WANG X H, et al. Estimation of the sources of organophosphorus pesticides in Xiamen sea area[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae, 2005, 25(8): 1071-1077.
[7]	王凌, 黎先春, 殷月芬, 等. 莱州湾水体中有机磷农药的残留监测与风险影响评价[J]. 安全与环境学报, 2007, 7(3): 83-85.
	WANG L, LEE F S C, YIN Y F, et al. Organophosphate pesticide residue monitoring and risk assessment in the sea-water from Laizhou Bay[J]. Journal of Safety and Environment, 2007, 7(3): 83-85.
[8]	解满俊, 董欣悦, 李梦娜, 等. 东部近海海产品中有机磷和敌草隆农药的残留特征与健康风险评估[J]. 环境科学研究, 2024, 37(9): 2054-2063.
	XIE M J, DONG X Y, LI M N, et al. Residue characteristics and health risk assessment of organophosphorus and diuron in seafood along the eastern coast of China[J]. Research of Environmental Sciences, 2024, 37(9): 2054-2063.
[9]	杨琳, 温裕云, 弓振斌. 加速溶剂萃取-液相色谱-串级质谱法测定近岸及河口沉积物中的拟除虫菊酯农药[J]. 分析化学, 2010, 38(7): 968-972.
	YANG L, WEN Y Y, GONG Z B. Determination of pyrethroid pesticides in estuarine and coastal sediments by accelerated solvent extraction and liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry[J]. Chinese Journal of Analytical Chemistry, 2010, 38(7): 968-972.
[10]	蓝草, 欧阳少伦, 邹游, 等. 液相色谱-串联质谱法测定水产品中甲氨基阿维菌素的残留量[J]. 理化检验:化学分册, 2023, 59(12): 1401-1406.
	LAN C, OUYANG S L, ZOU Y, et al. Determination of residue of emamectin in aquatic products by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry[J]. Physical Testing and Chemical Analysis Part B: Chemical Analysis, 2023, 59(12): 1401-1406.
[11]	黄武, 章晶晶, 刘辉, 等. QuEChERS结合在线凝胶渗透色谱-气相色谱-质谱联用法快速检测水产品中农药残留[J]. 食品安全质量检测学报, 2016, 7(2): 746-754.
	HUANG W, ZHANG J J, LIU H, et al. Rapid determination of pesticide residues in aquatic products by QuEChERS and on-line gel permeation chromatography-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry[J]. Journal of Food Safety & Quality, 2016, 7(2): 746-754.
[12]	CASTILLO M, GONZÁLEZ C, MIRALLES A. An evaluation method for determination of non-polar pesticide residues in animal fat samples by using dispersive solid-phase extraction clean-up and GC-MS[J]. Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 2011, 400(5): 1315-1328.
[13]	王曦, 刘子琪, 康珊珊, 等. 农药残留膳食暴露评估模型研究进展[J]. 食品科学, 2023, 44(3): 269-277.
	WANG X, LIU Z Q, KANG S S, et al. Research progress on assessment models for dietary exposure to pesticide residues[J]. Food Science, 2023, 44(3): 269-277.
[14]	付朝伟. 山东省市售果蔬中25种有机磷农药残留状况分析及膳食暴露风险研究[D]. 保定: 河北大学, 2024.
	FU C W. Analysis of 25 organophosphorus pesticide residues in fruits and vegetables sold in Shandong Province and a study on the risk of dietary exposure[D]. Baoding: Hebei University, 2024.
[15]	刘霞丽, 姚晓洁, 宁亚萍, 等. 河南省韭菜中农药残留情况分析及膳食暴露评估[J]. 中国食品卫生杂志, 2023, 35(2): 230-236.
	LIU X L, YAO X J, NING Y P, et al. Detection and exposure assessment of pesticide residues in leek in Henan Province[J]. Chinese Journal of Food Hygiene, 2023, 35(2): 230-236.
[16]	RENWICK A G. Pesticide residue analysis and its relationship to hazard characterisation (ADI/ARfD) and intake estimations (NEDI/NESTI)[J]. Pest Management Science, 2002, 58(10): 1073-1082.
[17]	张艳丽, 张艺潇, 陈燕玲, 等. 甘肃省苹果农药残留分析及风险评估[J]. 食品安全质量检测学报, 2024, 15(4): 194-202.
	ZHANG Y L, ZHANG Y X, CHEN Y L, et al. Analysis and risk assessment of pesticide residue in apples in Gansu Province[J]. Journal of Food Safety & Quality, 2024, 15(4): 194-202.
[18]	李卫东, 朱雷鹰, 彭勃, 等. 上海奉贤区草莓中农药多残留监测和风险评估[J]. 上海农业学报, 2025, 41(1): 80-87.
	LI W D, ZHU L Y, PENG B, et al. Monitoring and risk assessment of multi-pesticide residues in strawberries in Fengxian District, Shanghai[J]. Acta Agriculturae Shanghai, 2025, 41(1): 80-87.
[19]	潘丽英, 虞益江, 杨桂玲, 等. 浙江省韭菜中常用杀菌剂多残留分析及膳食暴露风险评估[J]. 现代食品科技, 2024, 40(7): 286-295.
	PAN L Y, YU Y J, YANG G L, et al. Multi-residue analysis and dietary exposure risk assessment of common fungicides in Chinese chives from Zhejiang Province[J]. Modern Food Science and Technology, 2024, 40(7): 286-295.
[20]	曹军, 陈勇, 杨瑞章, 等. 分散固相萃取分离-气相色谱法测定银鱼中拟除虫菊酯类农药残留量[J]. 理化检验:化学分册, 2010, 46(10): 1176-1178.
	CAO J, CHEN Y, YANG R Z, et al. GC determination of residual amount of pyrethroid pesticides in whitebait with separation by dispersive solid phase extraction[J]. Physical Testing and Chemical Analysis Part B: Chemical Analysis, 2010, 46(10): 1176-1178.
[21]	郑文慧, 叶江雷, 王秀彬, 等. 分散固相萃取法在农药残留检测中应用的进展[J]. 分析仪器, 2011(4): 23-27.
	ZHENG W H, YE J L, WANG X B, et al. Application progress of dispersive solid-phase extraction in determination of pesticide residues[J]. Analytical Instrumentation, 2011(4): 23-27.
[22]	张聪, 周常义, 江锋, 等. 超高效液相色谱-串联质谱法测定动物性食品中10种拟除虫菊酯类农药残留[J]. 分析测试学报, 2018, 37(8): 887-893.
	ZHANG C, ZHOU C Y, JIANG F, et al. Determination of 10 pyrethroid pesticide residues in animal foods by ultra performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry[J]. Journal of Instrumental Analysis, 2018, 37(8): 887-893.
[23]	LEHOTAY S J, KOK A D, HIEMSTRA M, et al. Validation of a fast and easy method for the determination of residues from 229 pesticides in fruits and vegetables using gas and liquid chromatography and mass spectrometric detection[J]. Journal of AOAC International, 2005, 88(2): 595-614.
[24]	何红梅, 赵华, 张春荣, 等. 超高效液相色谱-串联质谱法测定水稻基质中阿维菌素残留量[J]. 分析化学, 2012, 40(1): 140-144.
	HE H M, ZHAO H, ZHANG C R, et al. Determination of abamectin residue in paddy rice by ultra performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry[J]. Chinese Journal of Analytical Chemistry, 2012, 40(1): 140-144.
[25]	夏宝林, 严秋钫, 杨娜, 等. 增强型除脂固相萃取技术结合超高效液相色谱-串联质谱法测定动物源性食品中五氯酚残留量[J]. 食品安全质量检测学报, 2019, 10(14): 4698-4705.
	XIA B L, YAN Q F, YANG N, et al. Determination of pentachlorophenol residue in animal-origin foods by EMR-lipid-ultra performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry[J]. Journal of Food Safety & Quality, 2019, 10(14): 4698-4705.
[26]	吴洪喜, 柴雪良. 浙江乐清湾泥蚶的繁殖习性和生长特性[J]. 动物学杂志, 2004, 39(3): 47-50.
	WU H X, CHAI X L. The reproductive habit and growth character of bloody clam Tegillarca granosa in Yueqing Bay[J]. Chinese Journal of Zoology, 2004, 39(3): 47-50.
[27]	吴树敬. 彩虹明樱蛤养殖技术初探[J]. 水产科技情报, 1992, 19(5): 136-138.
	WU S J. A Preliminary study on the cultivation technology of Moerella iridescens[J]. Fisheries Science & Technology Information, 1992, 19(5): 136-138.
[28]	STREHSE J S, MASER E. Marine bivalves as bioindicators for environmental pollutants with focus on dumped munitions in the sea: a review[J]. Marine Environmental Research, 2020, 158: 105006.
[29]	金衍健. 三唑磷在海洋环境中残留及生态环境影响研究: 以乐清湾为例[D]. 舟山: 浙江海洋大学, 2019.
	JIN Y J. Study on the residues of triazophos in marine environment and ecological environment: taking Yueqing Bay as an example[D]. Zhoushan: Zhejiang Ocean University, 2019.
[30]	赵学坤, 杨桂朋, 高先池. 久效磷在海洋沉积物上的吸附行为[J]. 环境化学, 2002, 21(5): 443-447.
	ZHAO X K, YANG G P, GAO X C. Sorption behaviors of monocrotophos on marine sediments[J]. Environmental Chemistry, 2002, 21(5): 443-447.
[31]	钟志, 郭远明, 刘琴, 等. 三唑磷在海洋环境中的行为[J]. 环境化学, 2007, 26(5): 704-705.
	ZHONG Z, GUO Y M, LIU Q, et al. The behavior of triazole phosphorus in marine environments[J]. Environmental Chemistry, 2007, 26(5): 704-705.
[32]	陈容, 杨桂朋, 周立敏, 等. 三唑磷在水体系中的光化学降解研究[J]. 中国海洋大学学报, 2010, 40(S1): 185-190.
	CHEN R, YANG G P, ZHOU L M, et al. Study on photochemical degradation of triazophos in aqueous solutions[J]. Periodical of Ocean University of China, 2010, 40(S1): 185-190.
[33]	WHO (World Health Organization). Food Safety Collaborative Platform[DB/OL]. [2025-05-12]. https://apps.who.int/foscollab/Download/DownloadConso.
[34]	WHO (World Health Organization). Inventory of evaluations performed by the Joint Meeting on Pesticide Residues (JMPR)[DB/OL]. [2025-05-12]. http://apps.who.int/pesticide-residues-jmpr-database/Home/Range/All.
[35]	舒小桂, 张媚玉, 贺利民. 食品中拟除虫菊酯类农药残留检测前处理技术研究进展[J]. 食品安全质量检测学报, 2019, 10(18): 6157-6164.
	SHU X G, ZHANG M Y, HE L M. Advances in pretreatment of pyrethroid residues in foodstuffs[J]. Journal of Food Safety & Quality, 2019, 10(18): 6157-6164.

药剂 Reagent	母离子 Parent ion	子离子 Daughter ion	锥孔电压/V Cone voltage/V	碰撞能量/eV Collision energy/eV
甲胺磷Methamidophos	142.1	94.0^*/125.0	30	10/10
敌敌畏Dichlorvos	221.2	109.0^*/127.0	30	15/20
乐果Dimethoate	230.1	199.0^*/125.0	30	10/20
敌百虫Trichlorfon	257.1	109.0^*/221.0	30	18/10
对硫磷Parathion	292.2	236.0^*/264.0	30	15/10
辛硫磷Phoxim	299.0	129.0^*/153.0	30	15/5
三唑磷Triazophos	314.0	162.0^*/119.1	30	20/35
马拉硫磷Malathion	331.1	127.0^*/285.0	30	10/15
甲氰菊酯Fenpropathrin	350.3	125.2^*/97.2	20	15/25
氯菊酯Permethrin	408.5	183.1^*/355.2	20	20/5
氯氰菊酯Cypermethrin	433.1	191.0^*/127.0	30	10/30
氰戊菊酯Fenvalerate	437.2	167.0^*/208.0	20	20/10
氟氰戊菊酯Flucythrinate	469.2	412.2^*/199.2	20	10/16
溴氰菊酯Deltamethrin	523.2	280.9^*/506.0	20	15/10
阿维菌素Abamectin	895.5	751.5^*/449.0	30	40/50
伊维菌素Ivermectin	897.5	753.4^*/329.2	30	45/52

药剂 Reagent	母离子 Parent ion	子离子 Daughter ion	锥孔电压/V Cone voltage/V	碰撞能量/eV Collision energy/eV
甲胺磷Methamidophos	142.1	94.0^*/125.0	30	10/10
敌敌畏Dichlorvos	221.2	109.0^*/127.0	30	15/20
乐果Dimethoate	230.1	199.0^*/125.0	30	10/20
敌百虫Trichlorfon	257.1	109.0^*/221.0	30	18/10
对硫磷Parathion	292.2	236.0^*/264.0	30	15/10
辛硫磷Phoxim	299.0	129.0^*/153.0	30	15/5
三唑磷Triazophos	314.0	162.0^*/119.1	30	20/35
马拉硫磷Malathion	331.1	127.0^*/285.0	30	10/15
甲氰菊酯Fenpropathrin	350.3	125.2^*/97.2	20	15/25
氯菊酯Permethrin	408.5	183.1^*/355.2	20	20/5
氯氰菊酯Cypermethrin	433.1	191.0^*/127.0	30	10/30
氰戊菊酯Fenvalerate	437.2	167.0^*/208.0	20	20/10
氟氰戊菊酯Flucythrinate	469.2	412.2^*/199.2	20	10/16
溴氰菊酯Deltamethrin	523.2	280.9^*/506.0	20	15/10
阿维菌素Abamectin	895.5	751.5^*/449.0	30	40/50
伊维菌素Ivermectin	897.5	753.4^*/329.2	30	45/52

组别 Group	不同农药的提取率Extraction rate of different reagents
组别 Group	甲胺磷 Methamidophos	敌敌畏 Dichlorvos	乐果 Dimethoate	敌百虫 Trichlorfon	对硫磷 Parathion	辛硫磷 Phoxim	三唑磷 Triazophos	马拉硫磷 Malathion
G1	82.42±2.00 b	64.28±1.18 c	58.55±1.75 a	181.52±0.69 a	101.96±0.40 b	98.37±1.39 c	123.09±0.36 a	99.77±1.48 c
G2	89.69±6.44 ab	120.10±7.21 a	62.59±5.33 a	36.27±3.15 d	104.37±3.44 ab	104.86±1.09 ab	117.97±2.90 b	105.39±1.54 b
G3	94.02±3.38 a	106.88±2.18 b	65.47±3.54 a	67.35±3.55 b	107.05±1.72 a	103.66±1.15 b	122.45±0.10 a	109.31±0.83 a
G4	93.20±2.54 a	102.29±1.05 b	62.48±3.73 a	59.72±2.36 c	107.53±2.51 a	106.85±1.45 a	122.66±0.61 a	107.18±0.74 ab
G5	89.97±4.15 ab	115.21±2.52 a	62.48±4.44 a	34.66±3.68 d	105.52±2.24 ab	104.41±1.55 ab	118.63±1.89 b	104.65±2.78 b
组别 Group	不同农药的提取率Extraction rate of different reagents
组别 Group	甲氰菊酯 Fenpropathrin	氯菊酯 Permethrin	氯氰菊酯 Cypermethrin	氰戊菊酯 Fenvalerate	氟氰戊菊酯 Flucythrinate	溴氰菊酯 Deltamethrin	阿维菌素 Abamectin	伊维菌素 Ivermectin
G1	101.30±3.64 bc	85.14±8.01 a	101.075±7.31 a	98.39±7.42 ab	98.16±2.31 b	97.66±1.35 a	70.28±0.10 b	65.22±0.86 d
G2	104.61±4.66 ab	87.27±7.34 a	96.52±1.39 a	95.42±8.33 b	107.24±3.75 a	100.80±3.43 a	71.77±2.49 b	69.08±1.54 cd
G3	108.32±2.50 a	94.40±4.14 a	91.78±17.06 a	115.18±9.64 a	112.20±2.86 a	101.47±2.66 a	82.58±2.82 a	84.70±2.46 a
G4	105.38±2.19 ab	89.57±5.66 a	103.86±2.15 a	87.60±5.97 b	109.31±5.28 a	102.75±3.34 a	81.23±0.51 a	78.41±1.53 b
G5	96.93±1.75 c	83.74±3.30 a	101.86±4.63 a	102.41±10.14 ab	105.85±6.43 ab	99.93±0.91 a	72.58±1.32 b	70.18±7.49 c

组别 Group	不同农药的提取率Extraction rate of different reagents
组别 Group	甲胺磷 Methamidophos	敌敌畏 Dichlorvos	乐果 Dimethoate	敌百虫 Trichlorfon	对硫磷 Parathion	辛硫磷 Phoxim	三唑磷 Triazophos	马拉硫磷 Malathion
G1	82.42±2.00 b	64.28±1.18 c	58.55±1.75 a	181.52±0.69 a	101.96±0.40 b	98.37±1.39 c	123.09±0.36 a	99.77±1.48 c
G2	89.69±6.44 ab	120.10±7.21 a	62.59±5.33 a	36.27±3.15 d	104.37±3.44 ab	104.86±1.09 ab	117.97±2.90 b	105.39±1.54 b
G3	94.02±3.38 a	106.88±2.18 b	65.47±3.54 a	67.35±3.55 b	107.05±1.72 a	103.66±1.15 b	122.45±0.10 a	109.31±0.83 a
G4	93.20±2.54 a	102.29±1.05 b	62.48±3.73 a	59.72±2.36 c	107.53±2.51 a	106.85±1.45 a	122.66±0.61 a	107.18±0.74 ab
G5	89.97±4.15 ab	115.21±2.52 a	62.48±4.44 a	34.66±3.68 d	105.52±2.24 ab	104.41±1.55 ab	118.63±1.89 b	104.65±2.78 b
组别 Group	不同农药的提取率Extraction rate of different reagents
组别 Group	甲氰菊酯 Fenpropathrin	氯菊酯 Permethrin	氯氰菊酯 Cypermethrin	氰戊菊酯 Fenvalerate	氟氰戊菊酯 Flucythrinate	溴氰菊酯 Deltamethrin	阿维菌素 Abamectin	伊维菌素 Ivermectin
G1	101.30±3.64 bc	85.14±8.01 a	101.075±7.31 a	98.39±7.42 ab	98.16±2.31 b	97.66±1.35 a	70.28±0.10 b	65.22±0.86 d
G2	104.61±4.66 ab	87.27±7.34 a	96.52±1.39 a	95.42±8.33 b	107.24±3.75 a	100.80±3.43 a	71.77±2.49 b	69.08±1.54 cd
G3	108.32±2.50 a	94.40±4.14 a	91.78±17.06 a	115.18±9.64 a	112.20±2.86 a	101.47±2.66 a	82.58±2.82 a	84.70±2.46 a
G4	105.38±2.19 ab	89.57±5.66 a	103.86±2.15 a	87.60±5.97 b	109.31±5.28 a	102.75±3.34 a	81.23±0.51 a	78.41±1.53 b
G5	96.93±1.75 c	83.74±3.30 a	101.86±4.63 a	102.41±10.14 ab	105.85±6.43 ab	99.93±0.91 a	72.58±1.32 b	70.18±7.49 c

组别 Group	不同农药的提取率Extraction rate of different reagents
组别 Group	甲胺磷 Methamidophos	敌敌畏 Dichlorvos	乐果 Dimethoate	敌百虫 Trichlorfon	对硫磷 Parathion	辛硫磷 Phoxim	三唑磷 Triazophos	马拉硫磷 Malathion
G1	85.20±2.01 a	60.55±1.88 d	58.44±0.11 b	154.88±4.93 a	102.71±2.86 c	100.41±2.33 b	121.31±2.87 ab	99.33±1.44 c
G2	87.07±2.64 a	121.47±2.01 a	63.76±0.55 a	28.50±3.35 c	105.34±1.57 bc	104.18±2.15 a	118.61±0.49 b	103.97±1.35 b
G3	87.50±6.22 a	105.88±2.21 c	63.63±0.81 a	58.32±1.87 b	110.27±1.93 a	105.69±1.43 a	124.63±1.40 a	107.45±2.85 a
G4	90.68±1.29 a	102.86±2.07 c	60.15±1.69 b	52.55±1.47 b	106.65±1.05 ab	105.07±0.44 a	121.75±1.90 ab	104.97±0.85 ab
G5	85.94±5.17 a	115.52±3.70 b	63.17±0.56 a	30.85±1.68 c	105.63±1.70 bc	104.93±1.17 a	120.35±1.71 b	102.28±0.58 bc
组别 Group	不同农药的提取率Extraction rate of different reagents
组别 Group	甲氰菊酯 Fenpropathrin	氯菊酯 Permethrin	氯氰菊酯 Cypermethrin	氰戊菊酯 Fenvalerate	氟氰戊菊酯 Flucythrinate	溴氰菊酯 Deltamethrin	阿维菌素 Abamectin	伊维菌素 Ivermectin
G1	97.48±3.99 b	78.24±8.80 a	96.42±2.54 bc	99.02±2.19 ab	100.64±3.85 c	98.54±0.87 ab	67.92±4.18 b	55.93±1.04 b
G2	101.75±1.09 ab	78.62±2.70 a	90.66±5.37 c	84.80±13.26 b	110.30±3.34 a	102.26±1.63 a	65.82±2.16 b	56.16±2.56 b
G3	106.15±4.02 a	76.51±8.01 a	107.39±7.41 a	116.93±9.68 a	113.31±2.50 a	98.80±2.15 ab	82.32±3.59 a	60.91±1.97 a
G4	101.30±1.00 ab	79.70±1.80 a	103.15±2.76 ab	94.58±8.15 ab	107.56±2.58 ab	99.92±2.47 ab	78.07±1.86 a	55.57±0.38 b
G5	98.43±4.05 b	74.02±3.04 a	101.10±4.73 ab	83.87±21.82 b	103.42±4.44 bc	97.63±2.96 b	67.63±3.11 b	52.62±2.09 b

滩涂贝类及其养殖环境中16种农药残留的同步检测与膳食暴露风险评估

Simultaneous detection and dietary exposure risk assessment of 16 pesticides in mudflat shellfish and mariculture environment

RichHTML

PDF (PC)

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

图/表 10

参考文献 35

相关文章 15

编辑推荐

Metrics

本文评价

药剂 Reagent	在不同样本中的基质因子Matrix factor in different samples
药剂 Reagent	缢蛏 Sinonovacula constricta	泥蚶 Mud clam	彩虹明樱蛤 Moerella iridescens	海水 Sea water	沉积物 Sediment
甲胺磷Methamidophos	1.09	1.16	0.78	1.05	0.80
敌敌畏Dichlorvos	1.07	1.15	0.67	1.05	0.85
乐果Dimethoate	0.65	0.71	0.41	0.65	0.46
敌百虫Trichlorfon	0.70	0.74	0.46	0.70	0.51
对硫磷Parathion	1.04	1.06	0.68	1.04	0.77
辛硫磷Phoxim	0.92	1.01	0.74	1.01	0.77
三唑磷Triazophos	1.01	1.04	0.88	1.03	0.87
马拉硫磷Malathion	0.99	1.03	0.75	1.02	0.82
甲氰菊酯Fenpropathrin	0.90	0.99	0.64	1.01	0.86
氯菊酯Permethrin	0.68	0.79	0.60	0.92	0.84
氯氰菊酯Cypermethrin	1.06	1.05	0.86	1.01	0.91
氰戊菊酯Fenvalerate	0.87	0.85	0.59	0.92	0.79
氟氰戊菊酯Flucythrinate	1.12	1.10	0.74	1.03	0.83
溴氰菊酯Deltamethrin	0.95	0.98	0.65	1.00	0.88
阿维菌素Abamectin	1.42	1.20	1.33	0.96	1.02
伊维菌素Ivermectin	1.17	1.18	1.03	1.08	1.04

药剂 Reagent	在不同样品中的LOD LOD in different samples			在不同样品中的LOQ LOQ in different samples
药剂 Reagent	贝类/ (μg·kg^-1) Shellfish/ (μg·kg^-1)	沉积物/ (μg·kg^-1) Sediment/ (μg·kg^-1)	海水/ (μg·L^-1) Sea water/ (μg·L^-1)	贝类/ (μg·kg^-1) Shellfish/ (μg·kg^-1)	沉积物/ (μg·kg^-1) Sediment/ (μg·kg^-1)	海水/ (μg·L¹) Sea water/ (μg·L¹)
甲胺磷Methamidophos	1.0	1.0	1.5	3.0	4.0	4.5
敌敌畏Dichlorvos	1.0	1.0	1.5	3.0	4.0	4.5
乐果Dimethoate	1.0	1.0	1.0	3.0	3.0	3.0
敌百虫Trichlorfon	1.0	1.0	1.0	3.0	3.0	3.0
对硫磷Parathion	1.3	1.3	1.3	4.0	4.0	4.0
辛硫磷Phoxim	0.8	0.8	0.8	2.5	2.5	2.5
三唑磷Triazophos	0.033	0.15	0.15	0.1	0.5	0.5
马拉硫磷Malathion	0.05	0.25	0.3	0.2	0.8	0.8
甲氰菊酯Fenpropathrin	1.2	2.0	3.0	4.0	6.0	10.0
氯菊酯Permethrin	1.2	3.2	3.5	4.0	10.0	10.0
氯氰菊酯Cypermethrin	2.0	2.5	2.0	4.0	7.5	6.0
氰戊菊酯Fenvalerate	2.0	3.3	3.4	4.0	10.0	10.0
氟氰戊菊酯Flucythrinate	1.2	3.1	3.5	4.0	10.0	10.0
溴氰菊酯Deltamethrin	1.2	3.0	3.0	4.0	10.0	10.0
阿维菌素Abamectin	1.0	1.0	1.0	3.0	3.0	3.0
伊维菌素Ivermectin	1.0	1.0	1.0	3.0	3.0	3.0

药剂 Reagent	添加浓度/ (μg·kg^-1) Spiked dose/ (μg·kg^-1)	不同样品中的回收率/% Recovery rate in different samples/%			药剂 Reagent	添加浓度/ (μg·kg^-1) Spiked dose/ (μg·kg^-1)	不同样品中的回收率/% Recovery rate in different samples/%
药剂 Reagent	添加浓度/ (μg·kg^-1) Spiked dose/ (μg·kg^-1)	贝类 Shellfish	海水 Sea water	沉积物 Sediment	药剂 Reagent	添加浓度/ (μg·kg^-1) Spiked dose/ (μg·kg^-1)	贝类 Shellfish	海水 Sea water	沉积物 Sediment
甲胺磷	4	87.88±3.12	—	—	甲氰菊酯	4	98.75±5.29	—	—
Methamidophos	10	80.47±9.11	87.00±10.25	78.87±5.26	Fenpropathrin	10	98.73±4.49	100.38±4.46	106.87±4.62
	20	73.09±5.63	76.17±4.18	82.25±4.05		20	103.46±5.43	104.11±0.82	105.05±1.26
	50	83.27±1.38	81.11±3.06	80.92±3.19		50	107.46±1.54	102.56±1.62	103.86±1.73
敌敌畏	4	65.21±2.24	—	—	氯菊酯	4	81.63±1.47	—	—
Dichlorvos	10	69.28±7.22	99.67±2.36	88.98±4.36	Permethrin	10	96.17±9.27	107.88±10.15	115.58±2.53
	20	73.31±4.98	95.57±0.85	92.59±2.11		20	88.50±4.89	102.61±3.53	89.53±5.46
	50	85.68±3.80	96.79±0.83	94.37±1.72		50	103.16±4.94	105.87±5.97	107.08±2.27
乐果	4	104.13±1.01	—	—	氯氰菊酯	4	97.04±1.34	—	—
Dimethoate	10	102.50±4.54	103.93±1.72	93.23±1.02	Cypermethrin	10	98.63±5.17	104.95±5.76	106.80±6.96
	20	102.48±2.95	99.51±1.98	93.85±3.25		20	111.79±0.50	105.14±3.90	99.44±9.86
	50	105.65±4.48	98.92±2.29	97.86±4.38		50	115.74±3.17	105.26±3.42	100.24±0.43
敌百虫	4	103.17±1.37	—	—	氰戊菊酯	4	68.82±4.03	—	—
Trichlorfon	10	100.05±3.84	96.67±1.93	88.01±1.43	Fenvalerate	10	75.65±0.64	100.57±7.52	84.02±3.17
	20	97.10±4.39	93.26±2.76	88.72±3.34		20	101.88±0.74	91.68±6.93	84.02±7.34
	50	100.82±3.13	93.10±3.15	91.99±3.55		50	100.71±11.17	89.15±2.45	102.70±6.92
对硫磷	4	106.25±1.74	—	—	氟氰戊菊酯	4	73.42±3.71	—	—
Parathion	10	111.50±2.82	114.43±1.41	108.88±0.25	Flucythrinate	10	101.02±5.99	100.17±7.57	96.97±4.07
	20	100.75±0.66	106.58±0.75	105.70±3.50		20	100.42±8.40	98.66±2.71	107.01±1.53
	50	108.30±3.43	104.95±0.43	103.64±1.65		50	113.51±2.32	103.33±3.60	105.62±2.12
辛硫磷	4	103.50±1.41	—	—	溴氰菊酯	4	96.96±1.98	—	—
Phoxim	10	99.67±2.58	106.63±1.95	100.08±3.94	Deltamethrin	10	93.53±3.94	107.80±3.17	100.07±1.74
	20	101.31±2.64	103.31±0.99	102.15±0.49		20	104.17±1.59	100.98±2.37	100.22±9.94
	50	106.10±1.58	104.93±0.24	105.11±1.81		50	107.06±2.19	103.92±1.81	94.49±0.56
三唑磷	4	104.46±1.83	—	—	阿维菌素	4	97.50±4.02	—	—
Triazophos	10	113.32±2.92	110.63±1.10	102.27±2.92	Abamectin	10	90.92±5.64	98.18±3.15	89.88±6.11
	20	120.00±2.28	112.18±0.37	108.58±0.97		20	96.11±5.03	90.52±1.31	85.00±6.04
	50	118.87±0.98	115.71±0.28	112.22±1.18		50	97.34±2.14	96.05±2.51	88.98±2.63
马拉硫磷	4	94.79±3.43	—	—	伊维菌素	4	95.46±3.89	—	—
Malathion	10	96.08±0.74	107.48±1.94	98.58±2.81	Ivermectin	10	86.25±6.11	88.68±1.15	80.00±1.95
	20	100.06±2.96	105.28±1.16	103.34±0.94		20	89.76±3.47	88.78±0.77	83.13±2.71
	50	107.97±1.29	107.05±0.45	105.12±1.42		50	90.34±0.87	91.84±0.56	87.15±2.20

人群 Population	(C/m)/ (g·d^-1· kg^-1)	急性风险/% Acute risk/%
人群 Population	(C/m)/ (g·d^-1· kg^-1)	甲氰菊酯 Fenpropathrin	三唑磷 Triazophos
全部All	3.623 2	1.363	15.355
0~35月龄0-35 months	2.247 2	0.845	9.524
3~5岁3-5 years old	12.222 2	4.597	51.798
6~14岁6-14 years old	5.583 1	2.100	23.661
15~49岁15-49 years old	3.182 9	1.197	13.489
50~74岁50-74 years old	2.445 0	0.920	10.362
≥75岁≥75 years old	2.247 2	0.845	9.524

人群 Population	每日平均消费量/(g·d^-1) Daily consumption/(g·d^-1)	慢性风险/% Chronic risk/%
人群 Population	每日平均消费量/(g·d^-1) Daily consumption/(g·d^-1)	甲氰菊酯Fenpropathrin	三唑磷Triazophos
全部All	0.958 0	0.007	0.025
0~35月龄0-35 months	1.336 2	0.009	0.035
3~5岁3-5 years old	2.522 2	0.017	0.066
6~14岁6-14 years old	1.692 6	0.054	0.207
15~49岁15-49 years old	0.864 0	0.096	0.370
50~74岁50-74 years old	0.709 4	0.119	0.459
≥75岁≥75 years old	0.826 1	0.150	0.578

[1]	楚天舒, 朱克白, 杨宇辰, 贺雪妮, 赵智强, 戴子扬, 程沈航, 汤树生. 基于吡虫啉生态风险值的鸡粪稻田承载力估算[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2026, 38(4): 745-754.
[2]	边晓霞, 施梦迪, 杨怡中, 范盈盈, 张雨晨, 王玉晶, 王富兰, 王成, 刘峰娟. 新疆无核白葡萄及其干制品的农药残留风险评估[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2026, 38(2): 372-382.
[3]	陈星星, 虞雯煊, 徐健炜, 张鹏. 裙带菜不同部位重金属含量特征分析及健康风险评估[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2025, 37(8): 1794-1804.
[4]	廖建华, 葛峰, 单迪迪, 续卫利, 蔡小宇, 吴文铸, 朱昱璇. 农药对土壤生物的生态风险评估现状与展望[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2025, 37(12): 2642-2648.
[5]	陈星星, 虞雯煊, 薛峰, 吴越. 温州海域水产品的重金属分布特征与健康风险评价[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2025, 37(11): 2354-2363.
[6]	王晓梅, 骆玉琴, 赵学平, 陆兰菲, 方楠, 王祥云, 蒋金花, 何红梅, 张昌朋, 王强. 氟吡菌酰胺在铁皮石斛中的残留与膳食风险[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2024, 36(7): 1666-1676.
[7]	焦丙炎, 史增录, 张学军, 张海涛, 于永良, 王堆金. 棉花播种监测系统设计与试验[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2024, 36(6): 1389-1399.
[8]	褚田芬, 雷玲, 李勤锋, 吴平, 洪文杰, 郑蔚然. 浙江省西瓜中农药残留风险评估[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2024, 36(5): 1153-1160.
[9]	杨林沛, 李金文, 沈根祥, 朱文俊, 陈小华, 陈诚, 梁利权. 基于高频数据的旱地降雨径流污染物输出特征研究[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2024, 36(2): 391-403.
[10]	刘玉红, 金检生, 陈丽萍, 孙彩霞. 黄桃中4种农药残留动态与风险评估[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2024, 36(2): 432-440.
[11]	梁秀美, 张维一, 陈官菊, 夏海涛, 郭秀珠, 何如意, 蒋佳铭, 林定鹏. 温州市杨梅农药残留与重金属污染特征及膳食摄入风险评估[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2024, 36(10): 2347-2357.
[12]	叶会, 陈瑜婷, 骆玉琴, 范续艳, 雷圆, 陆兰菲, 郝培培, 程有普, 张昌朋. 两种剂型吡唑醚菌酯在草莓中的残留及消解动态[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2023, 35(7): 1720-1728.
[13]	王国迪, 冯行利, 吴涛起, 汪彦欣, 吴慧明, 饶琼, 张莉丽. 杭州地区草地贪夜蛾田间动态分析与生物型鉴定[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2023, 35(5): 1116-1122.
[14]	张春荣, 郭钤, 孔丽萍, 吴园园, 林琴, 许振岚, 赵学平, 汤涛. 嘧菌酯在杨梅中的残留行为及膳食暴露风险评估[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2023, 35(4): 942-951.
[15]	余帅, 黄俊, 应俊杰, 张娟, 毛雪琴, 张治军, 吕要斌, 李龑. 香蕉皮粉末对黑腹果蝇的引诱活性及挥发物化学成分分析[J]. 浙江农业学报, 2023, 35(10): 2415-2424.

t/min	流动相A的体积分数/% Volumn fraction of mobile phase A/%	流动相B的体积分数/% Volumn fraction of mobile phase B/%
0	3	97
1.0	3	97
1.5	15	85
2.5	50	50
7.0	70	30
9.0	98	2
13.0	98	2
13.1	3	97
15.0	3	97

t/min	流动相A的体积分数/% Volumn fraction of mobile phase A/%	流动相B的体积分数/% Volumn fraction of mobile phase B/%
0	3	97
1.0	3	97
1.5	15	85
2.5	50	50
7.0	70	30
9.0	98	2
13.0	98	2
13.1	3	97
15.0	3	97

组别 Group	不同农药的提取率Extraction rate of different reagents
组别 Group	甲胺磷 Methamidophos	敌敌畏 Dichlorvos	乐果 Dimethoate	敌百虫 Trichlorfon	对硫磷 Parathion	辛硫磷 Phoxim	三唑磷 Triazophos	马拉硫磷 Malathion
G1	90.98±5.17 b	74.17±5.77 b	61.24±3.74 b	126.60±2.59 a	115.11±8.49 a	108.38±7.47 b	114.23±9.02 a	111.46±8.22 b
G2	107.15±5.39 a	117.97±2.02 a	64.50±1.03 ab	58.32±2.18 c	119.01±1.67 a	117.54±0.79 a	119.65±1.15 a	119.67±1.69 ab
G3	92.09±5.53 b	115.26±3.00 a	63.82±2.40 b	63.04±1.94 b	118.84±3.41 a	113.31±4.81 ab	120.93±3.88 a	118.21±2.31 ab
G4	94.19±8.15 b	121.01±1.42 a	68.63±1.06 a	63.14±0.49 b	122.38±1.47 a	117.37±1.30 a	123.46±0.74 a	121.15±1.86 a
G5	93.81±3.73 b	121.23±1.62 a	64.04±1.42 b	51.05±2.95 d	118.98±1.23 a	118.08±1.19 a	121.56±2.12 a	119.90±1.86 ab
组别 Group	不同农药的提取率Extraction rate of different reagents
组别 Group	甲氰菊酯 Fenpropathrin	氯菊酯 Permethrin	氯氰菊酯 Cypermethrin	氰戊菊酯 Fenvalerate	氟氰戊菊酯 Flucythrinate	溴氰菊酯 Deltamethrin	阿维菌素 Abamectin	伊维菌素 Ivermectin
G1	105.92±6.68 b	105.96±7.21 a	106.89±6.23 b	110.22±5.31 ab	109.05±13.64 a	108.04±9.74 a	83.47±2.67 c	82.40±4.81 b
G2	115.91±0.32 a	107.48±3.84 a	119.57±3.85 a	103.72±4.13 b	117.77±5.10 a	111.96±1.13 a	NOTE	NOTE
G3	114.29±2.59 a	100.38±1.62 a	114.45±1.45 ab	107.84±6.59 ab	112.76±2.97 a	109.42±3.61 a	101.95±5.05 a	106.19±6.69 a
G4	120.03±3.19 a	110.91±5.17 a	117.18±4.94 a	122.15±10.93 a	117.75±9.80 a	115.95±2.75 a	100.76±1.27 a	103.01±3.83 a
G5	114.63±2.90 a	103.69±5.27 a	114.04±3.98 ab	122.59±9.35 a	112.93±6.99 a	115.67±1.66 a	91.25±3.87 b	89.65±3.83 b

组别 Group	不同农药的提取率Extraction rate of different reagents
组别 Group	甲胺磷 Methamidophos	敌敌畏 Dichlorvos	乐果 Dimethoate	敌百虫 Trichlorfon	对硫磷 Parathion	辛硫磷 Phoxim	三唑磷 Triazophos	马拉硫磷 Malathion
G1	90.98±5.17 b	74.17±5.77 b	61.24±3.74 b	126.60±2.59 a	115.11±8.49 a	108.38±7.47 b	114.23±9.02 a	111.46±8.22 b
G2	107.15±5.39 a	117.97±2.02 a	64.50±1.03 ab	58.32±2.18 c	119.01±1.67 a	117.54±0.79 a	119.65±1.15 a	119.67±1.69 ab
G3	92.09±5.53 b	115.26±3.00 a	63.82±2.40 b	63.04±1.94 b	118.84±3.41 a	113.31±4.81 ab	120.93±3.88 a	118.21±2.31 ab
G4	94.19±8.15 b	121.01±1.42 a	68.63±1.06 a	63.14±0.49 b	122.38±1.47 a	117.37±1.30 a	123.46±0.74 a	121.15±1.86 a
G5	93.81±3.73 b	121.23±1.62 a	64.04±1.42 b	51.05±2.95 d	118.98±1.23 a	118.08±1.19 a	121.56±2.12 a	119.90±1.86 ab
组别 Group	不同农药的提取率Extraction rate of different reagents
组别 Group	甲氰菊酯 Fenpropathrin	氯菊酯 Permethrin	氯氰菊酯 Cypermethrin	氰戊菊酯 Fenvalerate	氟氰戊菊酯 Flucythrinate	溴氰菊酯 Deltamethrin	阿维菌素 Abamectin	伊维菌素 Ivermectin
G1	105.92±6.68 b	105.96±7.21 a	106.89±6.23 b	110.22±5.31 ab	109.05±13.64 a	108.04±9.74 a	83.47±2.67 c	82.40±4.81 b
G2	115.91±0.32 a	107.48±3.84 a	119.57±3.85 a	103.72±4.13 b	117.77±5.10 a	111.96±1.13 a	NOTE	NOTE
G3	114.29±2.59 a	100.38±1.62 a	114.45±1.45 ab	107.84±6.59 ab	112.76±2.97 a	109.42±3.61 a	101.95±5.05 a	106.19±6.69 a
G4	120.03±3.19 a	110.91±5.17 a	117.18±4.94 a	122.15±10.93 a	117.75±9.80 a	115.95±2.75 a	100.76±1.27 a	103.01±3.83 a
G5	114.63±2.90 a	103.69±5.27 a	114.04±3.98 ab	122.59±9.35 a	112.93±6.99 a	115.67±1.66 a	91.25±3.87 b	89.65±3.83 b